November 16, 2026
Key Takeaways:
Overview
In most private company acquisitions, the closing payment is based on estimates that are “trued up” after closing. The buyer delivers a closing statement, the seller may object, and items the parties cannot resolve go to an independent accounting firm. Whether that firm acts as an expert or an arbitrator is more than terminology: it can itself become the subject of litigation.
Why the Distinction Matters
Both roles typically produce a decision the agreement calls “final and binding,” but they differ in important ways:
|
Expert |
Arbitrator |
|
|---|---|---|
|
What it decides |
Only the specific accounting items properly raised in the objection notice, such as whether a reserve was calculated correctly; legal questions (contract interpretation, bad faith, indemnity) are left to a court |
Potentially the entire dispute, including what the contract means and other legal questions |
|
How the process works |
Informal and streamlined, usually based on written submissions, often with no hearing, discovery or formal rules, and completed within a short contractual period (frequently 30 days) |
Formal and court-like, often with rules, evidence, witnesses and hearings |
|
Cost and timing |
Generally faster and less expensive |
Generally slower and more expensive |
|
Finality, enforcement and challenges |
Typically, final and binding absent fraud or manifest error, and often the exclusive remedy for adjustment disputes; governed by contract law, so it is enforced (or challenged) through a breach of contract action, not confirmed under arbitration statutes |
Award can be confirmed and entered as a court judgment under the Federal Arbitration Act or state arbitration statutes; very limited statutory grounds to vacate |
What Should You Choose?
Using the accounting firm as an expert is the prevailing market practice, and Delaware courts have consistently construed standard accountant true-up provisions that way. The reasons are practical - accountants are best suited to resolve accounting questions, and a narrow expert process is fast and relatively inexpensive, while legal claims such as fraud or indemnity stay in court.
Arbitration nonetheless has real advantages worth weighing. An arbitrator can resolve the whole dispute, including legal questions, in one proceeding, and the award can be confirmed as a court judgment; an expert determination, by contrast, is enforceable only as a contract and can leave “accounting” and “legal” issues in parallel proceedings. The tradeoffs are cost, time and a decision on legal issues that is very difficult to overturn, and an accounting firm may be unsuited to serve as a full arbitrator.
Notwithstanding the market default, arbitration may make sense where, for example, the buyer is expected to recast working capital objections as breaches of financial statement representations, so one decision-maker can resolve both; where bespoke accounting principles invite disputes over what the contract requires rather than how to apply it; or where the agreement already sends all other disputes to confidential arbitration.
Labels Are Not the End of the Story
The words “as an expert and not as an arbitrator” are important but not always decisive. Delaware courts apply an “authority test,” examining what the accountant may decide (only the disputed items, or the dispute generally), the procedures (references to arbitral rules or institutions such as the AAA or JAMS, hearings, formal evidence) and finality (a short, fixed deadline, or an award to be entered as a judgment). A clause calling the accountant the “final arbiter” has been treated as an expert determination, and a clause silent on the point may be read either way. Governing law also matters, as not every state draws the line the same way.
Conclusion
The purchase price adjustment dispute provision is often treated as boilerplate, but it determines how, where and at what cost a post-closing dispute is resolved. Expert determination is the market default for good reason, but arbitration remains a legitimate choice when parties want a single forum and a court-enforceable award. In deciding between the two, parties should weigh the issues likely to arise after closing (purely computational disagreements versus disputes intertwined with contract interpretation or representations), the relative importance of speed and cost against finality and enforceability, and how the choice fits with the agreement’s general dispute resolution, governing law and indemnification provisions. Whichever route is chosen, the provision should state the intended role expressly and define the decision-maker’s scope of authority, procedures and finality consistently with that role. Consistent drafting is the best way to avoid a dispute over the dispute process itself.